Seat Belt Physical Evidence

Seat Belt Physical Evidence

Background

Seat belts dramatically reduce the risk of injury in motor vehicle collisions. Forensic investigation of automobile collisions commonly involves analysis of restraint system physical evidence to determine if a seat belt restraint system was used during a collision event.

This study presents examples of physical evidence collected from seat belt systems involved in real-world collisions, which were initially alleged to affirm proper belt use, but were ultimately proven to be evidence of non-use.

Approach

Several laboratory demonstrations were conducted to investigate physical evidence created on restraint system hardware as a result of pretensioner deployments of non-used seat belts in a variety of incompletely stowed conditions. Seat belt pretensioners are engineered to tighten the seat belt around the occupant during the early stages of moderate to severe crashes.  The demonstrations show the initial positions of the seat belt assemblies necessary to produce the distinct physical evidence documented in the real-world samples.

The photographs above show examples of collision-induced markings on non-used restraint systems from this study. These markings could easily be misinterpreted as evidence of seat belt use.


Takeaway

The characteristics of collision-induced markings generated on seat belt systems are not solely dependent on the belted status of the occupant, but also the technological features incorporated in the seat belt assembly. Pretensioner deployment can leave physical evidence on restraint system hardware and webbing in the absence of occupant loading and may be misinterpreted as evidence of seat belt use.

The presence of physical evidence on restraint system hardware and webbing is inadequate to conclude that a seat belt restraint was in use. Careful consideration of restraint system physical evidence combined with restraint system geometry and incorporated technological features can distinguish physical evidence related to seat belt use or non-use during a collision event.

Related Publication:

Gregg R. and Petroskey K. Assessment of Collision Markings on Non-Used Vehicle Restraint Systems. Society of Automotive Engineers. SAE 2020-01-0975.

back to research projects

Related Specialties

Related Research Projects

Read More →
Characterization of Occupant Lower Extremity Behavior During Moderate-to-High Speed Rear Impacts
Injury potential to the neck has been studied extensively for rear-end impacts.
Read More →
Assessment of Closed-Head Injury Risk during Moderately Severe Rear-End Collisions
It has been suggested that closed head injury can occur during low-to-moderate speed rear-end collisions.
Read More →
Disc Herniation Mechanism
Computer simulation programs provide researchers with cost-effective methodologies for studying internal stresses and loads on biological specimens.
Read More →
Pediatric Injury and “Shaken Baby Syndrome”
The objective of the current study was to evaluate pediatric neck and head injury potential during purely inertial loading of the head.
Read More →
Out of Position Analysis of Rear-End Collision Integrating Subject-Specific Posture
Kinetic and kinematic data collected from controlled low-speed rear-end crash tests are typically limited to normally seated volunteers, cadavers, and anthropomorphic test devices.
Read More →
Skull Fracture Origination
Forensic evaluations of fracture patterns arising from blunt force trauma to the human head have traditionally relied upon case studies rather than controlled experimental data.
Read More →
Biomechanical Analysis of Rear-End Collision Integrating Subject-Specific Posture & Vehicle Fit
Available kinematic and kinetic data with respect to low speed rear-end collisions are typically limited to volunteer, cadaver, and anthropomorphic test device.
Read More →
Disparate Patterns of Skull Fracture
Determining the etiology of skull trauma by analyzing the resulting fracture pattern is a common forensic objective that has been demonstrated to follow generalized trends.
Read More →
Hand and Foot Forces in Occupational Railcar Ascent
Falls from ladders are a major cause of worker injuries and fatalities.
Read More →
Visual Acuity and Contrast Sensitivity in a Virtual Environment
Virtual reality (VR) and head-mounted displays (HMDs) can be viable tools for the presentation of accurate and valid demonstrative data in the courtroom.
Read More →
Spatial Awareness and Depth Perception in Various Display Methodologies (e.g. 2D and 360 degree Photos/Videos, and Virtual Reality)
The ability to accurately depict the scene of an incident to a jury is a key element of presenting trial demonstratives.
Read More →
Smartphones and Driver/Pedestrian Distraction
Individuals interact with their smartphones throughout the dar, regardless of the activity they are performing.
Read More →
The Contribution of Posterior Spinal Muscles and Facet Joint Contact in Reducing Disk Herniation Risk
Disc herniations occur in a biomechanical environment consistent with forward bending, i.e. compression and flexion of the spine.
Read More →
Seat Belt Physical Evidence
Seat belts dramatically reduce the risk of injury in motor vehicle collisions.
Read More →
Headlamp Mapping and Nighttime Visibility
Vehicle headlamps and ambient lighting are the primary sources of light in nighttime driving scenarios.
back to research projects
Find the ideal expert today.

Each of our professionals offers a unique set of skills and experience and are ready to discuss your next project.

Find an Expert